The verdict
On the data we hold, it's close: neither pulls ahead on features, a free plan or AI access. The choice comes down to how you work.
Side by side
Plans and pricing
Circle
- Professional$1,068/yr
- Business$2,388/yr
- Scale$5,028/yr
Recurly
- Starter$249/mo
- Engage (add-on)$19,200/yr
- RevRec (add-on)$10,200/yr
Who each is for
Choose Circle if…
Creators, coaches, educators and membership businesses who want a branded paid community with courses, events and payments on one platform.
Choose Recurly if…
Subscription and digital commerce businesses with real billing volume, such as growing SaaS companies, that need failed-payment recovery, several gateways and billing handled outside their own code.
Other options worth a look
Spots churn risk early with health scoring, automated plays, and renewal forecasting for subscription businesses.
Brings customer data, usage and health scores together so B2B teams can onboard, retain and grow accounts.
Consolidates customer data, health scoring and team workflows in one workspace for customer success.
Track product usage and account health to flag churn risk and automate customer retention workflows.
Triggers email, SMS, push, in-app and WhatsApp messages from real-time user events and behaviour.