BigCommerce vs Sellfy

BigCommerce logovsSellfy logo
BigCommerce is a hosted store for growing retailers and B2B sellers who want APIs. Sellfy is a simple store for creators selling their own downloads, subscriptions and merchandise.

The verdict

If you are a creator selling ebooks, templates, courses or merchandise to an audience you already have, pick Sellfy. It gets you selling the same day, with secure file delivery included. If you sell physical products at scale, sell to businesses, or need your systems to talk to the store through APIs, pick BigCommerce.

The honest trade-off is control against speed. Sellfy has a ceiling on customisation, and moving off it later is real work. BigCommerce asks more of you at the start, but it bends further. For most small B2B teams, a catalogue with business buyers is a BigCommerce case. A creator selling their own work is a Sellfy case.

What the data says
  • Both cover 1 of the 1 features we compared.
  • Sellfy starts lower, at $22/mo against $29/mo.
  • In our Website ranking, BigCommerce places 7 and Sellfy 8 of 11.

Side by side

BigCommerce and Sellfy compared
5 points compared
Starts at$29/mo$22/mo
Free planNoNo
APIYesYes
MCP serverYesNot known yet
Native ecommerceYesYes
Links

Plans and pricing

BigCommerce logo

BigCommerce

  • CoreUp to 30,000 USD trailing twelve-month sales; auto-upgrades to Growth.$39/mo
  • GrowthUp to 100,000 USD trailing twelve-month sales; auto-upgrades to Scale.$105/mo
  • ScaleMonthly sales cap of 33,333 USD; 0.9 percent on sales above the cap.$399/mo
Sellfy logo

Sellfy

  • StarterUp to $10k in sales per year; $29 monthly or $22 per month billed yearly; 0% transaction fees.$29/mo
  • BusinessUp to $50k in sales per year; $79 monthly or $59 per month billed yearly; adds upselling and affiliates.$79/mo
  • PremiumUp to $200k in sales per year; $159 monthly or $119 per month billed yearly; priority support.$159/mo

Prices as the vendors list them. They change often; the final price is on their sites.

Who each is for

BigCommerce logo

Choose BigCommerce if…

Pick BigCommerce if your store is a core business system. It suits growing online retailers and B2B sellers that want documented APIs for orders, products and customers, plus features for business buyers that depend on your edition.

It also suits you if you want a developer to build around the store. Orders through embedded payment providers carry no platform fee, while open providers add a fee on that volume, so compare the combined cost. Plans have sales caps and upgrade themselves when you pass them. There is a 15-day trial with all features working, which is enough to test an integration. Skip it if you only sell a few downloads.

Sellfy logo

Choose Sellfy if…

Pick Sellfy if you make the things you sell. It suits creators and small brands with ebooks, templates, courses, subscriptions or print-on-demand merchandise who want a store, checkout and file delivery working within a day.

Download limits and PDF stamping help reduce unauthorised sharing, and you can embed buy buttons on any page. Email campaigns, upsells and affiliates sit in the same dashboard. The vendor lists Zapier and webhooks if you want to automate. Skip it if you run a large catalogue, complex inventory or tax set-ups, or want control of the storefront code. Ask how to export customers and orders before you build on it.

Other options worth a look

  • Webflow logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Builds responsive websites visually with a built-in CMS and ecommerce, producing HTML, CSS and JavaScript.

    Website

    From $15/mo yearlyFree planAffiliate link
  • Wix logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Builds business websites and online stores without coding, with hosting, payments and blogging built in.

    Website

    From $17.77/mo yearlyFree plan
  • Squarespace logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Build a polished marketing site or online store without managing hosting or writing code.

    Website

    From €12/mo yearly
  • Shopify logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Hosted online store platform that handles products, checkout, payments and orders for businesses selling online.

    Website

    From €21/mo yearlyFree plan
  • Framer logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Build and host responsive marketing sites with a visual canvas, built-in CMS and AI.

    Website

    From $10/moFree plan
  • Carrd logo
    ToolClient acquisition
    Builds simple responsive one-page websites without any code, using templates and drag-and-drop design.

    Website

    From $0.75/mo yearlyFree plan