The verdict
Pick ClickUp if you want maximum flexibility for the money: more views, deeper customisation and a cheaper paid entry point make it the better default for teams who want one tool to replace several. Pick Asana if ease of use and reliability matter more than feature count: it is the cleaner, calmer tool that a non-technical team adopts without training. ClickUp wins on breadth and price, Asana wins on polish and adoption. The honest question is whether you are buying power (ClickUp) or simplicity (Asana).