The verdict
If you want the deepest behavioural analysis with machine-learning predictions and a surface a non-technical marketer can drive, Amplitude is the stronger tool, and you pay for it as your tracked users grow. If you want every piece, analytics, replay, flags, experiments and a warehouse, in one engineer-first platform you can self-host, PostHog wins on breadth, on a genuinely generous free tier, and on the open-source ownership Amplitude simply does not offer.
The two rarely tie because they are built for different buyers. Amplitude is the better analytics product; PostHog is the better all-in-one platform. Pick on which of those you actually need, not on the feature list, because PostHog matches Amplitude on every headline feature in this comparison and then adds self-hosting on top.
We disclose any affiliate relationship on these pages, and our click-outs resolve server-side with no commission signal attached, so nothing about how we earn moves this ranking. It rests on the verified pricing and features alone.