Nickel vs Shoeboxed

NIvsSH
Two Bookkeeping tools side by side: what each does, what it costs and who it suits.

The verdict

On the data we hold, Nickel comes out ahead. Here is why, point by point.

What the data says
  • Only Nickel has a free plan to start on.
  • Shoeboxed starts lower, at $8.08/mo against $35/mo.
  • In our Bookkeeping ranking, Nickel places 7 and Shoeboxed 16 of 20.

Side by side

Nickel and Shoeboxed compared
At a glance
Starts at$35/mo$8.08/mo
Free planYesNo
APIYesYes
MCP serverNot known yetNo
Links

Plans and pricing

NI

Nickel

  • Plusrecurring invoices and autopay$45/mo
  • ProAPI access and compliance$300/mo
SH

Shoeboxed

  • Startersolopreneurs and sole proprietors$9/mo
  • Profreelancers and growing SMBs$29/mo
  • Plussmall teams and accountants$79/mo

Prices as the vendors list them. They change often; the final price is on their sites.

Who each is for

NI

Choose Nickel if…

We haven't written up who Nickel suits yet.
SH

Choose Shoeboxed if…

We haven't written up who Shoeboxed suits yet.

Other options worth a look

  • Xero logo
    Tool
    Cloud accounting with invoicing, bank reconciliation and reports, with no per-user licence fees on any plan.

    Bookkeeping

    From $27/mo
  • Exact Online logo
    Tool
    Bookkeeping and accounting software for managing business finances and keeping complete financial records.

    Bookkeeping

    From €49/mo
  • QuickBooks logo
    Tool
    Cloud accounting from Intuit for invoicing, expenses, bank feeds and reports, with a free plan and four paid tiers.

    Bookkeeping

    From $38/moFree plan
  • AS
    Tool
    Manages global business accounts, virtual corporate cards, and automated bookkeeping to streamline international spending and financial records.

    Bookkeeping

    From $180/moFree plan
  • NA
    Tool
    Consolidates corporate travel booking, expense management, and card payments into one AI-powered platform with policy enforcement.

    Bookkeeping

    From $15/moFree plan
  • ME
    Tool
    Automates business bill pay and vendor payments with OCR scanning, approval workflows and accounting software sync.

    Bookkeeping

    From $20/mo yearlyFree plan